The Expert Syndrome And Why You Are Passed On Promotion Cycles
How experienced leaders out stand domain experts in the workplace
It is Monday morning. You stare at the email subject line. Pulse quickening.
Another promotion cycle passes. Despite you knowing every intricate detail of the domain, you are overlooked. Another candidate has been chosen. Someone who knows far less about your organizational challenges. Still, that person was selected over you.
This is the bitter reality for many. You are not alone. It is a pattern I have observed countless times across late stage startups and tech giants. But why does that happen? Where have you fallen short?
The Signals You Are Falling Short
If that describes your frustrating experience, you are likely sending the wrong signals.
Your communication with leadership remains tactical. You are solving problems, not creating strategic outcomes. Your impact is measured by technical and domain complexity, not business results.
Most people believe internal company lore is their golden ticket. Not quite. That would always make the longest tenured employees being promoted first, which is unheard by most of us.
Don't get me wrong. Knowing our problem space at the detailed level is important. But that, alone, does not qualify you as the best choice.
To fix it, you have to first understand the fundamental expectations laid upon leadership.
The Bedrock of Successful Leadership
The most successful and high-trajectory leaders are the ones that:
Understand the business strategy in depth
Create alignment by sharing context
Ruthlessly prioritize important work
Selectively choose when and where to get involved
Delegate with clarity conveying the expected results
Domain expertise is the foundation. But the ability to enable the business strategy? That's your elevator to senior leadership.
The ability to drive results is the core truth of leadership excellence.
Signals of Strategic Transformation
You'll know you're making progress when specific transformation signals emerge. Senior leaders start proactively seeking your perspective on important matters. You are invited to strategic planning meetings. Senior leaders begin to trust you with minimal supervision on critical initiatives.
And most importantly...
Your recommendations are viewed as strategic insights, not just implementation alternatives.
Increasing Your Chances of Success
To fix it and increase your chances of success, you have to understand that:
Domain expertise alone is insufficient for leadership progression
Technical work only has impact when translated into business value
Strategic storytelling is critical for career advancement
Cross-functional partnership is equally important to technical depth
Impact must be quantified in business-oriented terms
Leadership is about selective, strategic involvement
Next week, we'll dive deeper into how you can capture important aspects of the business strategy and use it to craft your strategic narrative to become influential. Until then, start looking at your work through the lens of business impact.
Do you want to share your experience or challenges? Here are ways I can help:
Book a 30 min session to talk about career challenges
Follow me for actionable tips and advice on LinkedIn
Ask me a question by commenting on this post